Origin of the Andronovans: A Statistical Approach
https://doi.org/10.17746/1563-0110.2023.51.4.142-151
Abstract
The origin of the Andronovo population is explored using a statistical rather than typological approach. Four questions are raised. Which Eastern European populations of the Middle Bronze and the transition to the Late Bronze Age had taken part in Andronovo origins? What was the contribution of the southern groups? What was the role of the autochthonous Siberian substratum? What was the population background of the dichotomy between two major Andronovo cultural traditions, Fedorovka and Alakul? To address these questions, measurements of 12 male Andronovo cranial samples (nine relating to Fedorovka and three to Alakul) and 85 male cranial samples from Eastern Europe, Siberia, Kazakhstan, Southwestern Central Asia, Southern Caucasus, and the Near East were subjected to canonical variate analysis, and minimum spanning trees were constructed. The results suggest that the most likely ancestors of Andronovans were Late Catacomb tribes of Northern Caucasus, people of Poltavka, Sintashta, and those associated with the Abashevo-Sintashta horizon. While no direct parallels with Southern Caucasian, Southwestern Central Asian or Near Eastern populations were found among Andronovo groups, some of them could have inherited the southern component from either the Abashevo or the Catacomb people. In the former case, one should postulate a gradient: Fatyanovo → Balanovo → Abashevo → Sintashta → Petrovka → Andronovo; in the latter case, the variation within Andronovo is directly derivable from that among the Catacomb populations. Andronovo groups displaying an autochthonous Siberian tendency demonstrate various degrees of “mutual assimilation” between immigrants and pre-Mongoloid natives. Differences between the Fedorovka and Alakul samples are significant but very small. A special role of Petrovka in the origin of Alakul is not supported by the analysis.
Keywords
Southern Siberia,
Eastern Europe,
Late Bronze Age,
Andronovo culture,
Fedorovka tradition,
Alakul tradition
Supporting agencies: I am thankful to K.N. Solodovnikov and the late S.I. Kruts for granting me access to their unpublished data.
About the Author
A. G. Kozintsev
Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Chief Researcher, Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences.
Universitetskaya nab. 3, St. Petersburg, 199034
References
1. Akimova M.S. 1963 Paleoantropologicheskiye materialy iz Balanovskogo mogilnika. In Bader O.N. Balanovskiy mogilnik: Iz istorii lesnogo Povolzhiya v epokhu bronzy. Moscow: Izd. AN SSSR, pp. 322–362.
2. Alekseyev V.P. 1961 Paleoantropologiya Altaye-Sayanskogo nagoriya epokhi neolita i bronzy. In Antropologicheskiy sbornik, iss 3. Moscow, Leningrad: Izd. AN SSSR, pp. 107–206. (TIE, Nov. ser.; vol. 71).
3. Anthony D. 2019 Archaeology, genetics, and language in the steppes: A comment on Bomhard. Journal of Indo-European Studies, vol. 47 (1/2): 173–196.
4. Chikisheva T.A. 2012 Dinamika antropologicheskoi differentsiatsii naseleniya yuga Zapadnoi Sibiri v epokhi neolita – rannego zheleza. Novosibirsk: Izd. IAET SO RAN.
5. Chikisheva T.A., Pozdnyakov D.V. 2003 Andronovo populations of West Siberia: Cranial data. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, No. 3: 132–148.
6. Chikisheva T.A., Pozdnyakov D.V. 2019 The physical anthropology of the Odino people, Western Siberia. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 47 (4): 128–139.
7. Denisova R.Y. 1975 Antropologiya drevnikh baltov. Riga: Zinatne.
8. Dremov V.A. 1997 Naseleniye Verkhnego Priobiya v epokhu bronzy (antropologicheskiy ocherk). Tomsk: Izd. Tomsk. Gos. Univ.
9. Gokhman I.I. 1980 Proiskhozhdeniye tsentralnoaziatskoi rasy v svete novykh paleoantropologicheskikh materialov. In Issledovaniya po paleoantropologii i kraniologii SSSR. Moscow, Leningrad: Izd. AN SSSR, pp. 5–34. (Sbornik MAE; No. 36).
10. Gromov A.V. 1997 Proiskhozhdeniye i svyazi naseleniya okunevskoi kultury. In Okunevskiy sbornik. St. Petersburg: Petro-RIF, pp. 301–358.
11. Kazarnitsky A.A. 2011 Paleoantropologiya epokhi bronzy stepnoi polosy Yuga Vostochnoi Evropy. Cand. Sci. (History) Dissertation. IEA RAN. St. Petersburg.
12. Kazarnitsky A.A. 2012 Naseleniye azovo-kaspiyskikh stepei v epokhu bronzy (antropologicheskiy ocherk). St. Petersburg: Nauka.
13. Khalikov A.K., Lebedinskaya G.V., Gerasimova M.M. 1966 Abashevskaya kultura (Pepkinskiy chelovek). Ioshkar-Ola: Mari. kn. izd. (Trudy Mar. arkheol. ekspeditsii; vol. 3).
14. Khalyapin M.V. 2001 Pervyi beskurgannyi mogilnik sintashtinskoi kultury v stepnom Priuraliye. In Bronzovyi vek Vostochnoi Evropy: Kharakteristika kultur, khronologiya i periodizatsiya: Materialy Mezhdunar. nauch. konf. “K stoletiyu periodizatsii V.A. Gorodtsova bronzovogo veka yuzhnoi poloviny Vostochnoi Evropy”. Samara: Nauch.-tekhn. tsentr, pp. 417– 424.
15. Khodjayov T.K. 2004 Novye antropologicheskiye materialy epokh neolita i bronzy srednego i verkhnego Zarafshana. Vestnik antropologii, No. 11: 87–101.
16. Khodjayov T.K., Mustafakulov S.I., Khodjayova G.K. 2011 Paleoantropologiya yuga Srednei Azii epokhi eneolita i bronzy. Moscow: IAE RAN.
17. Khokhlov A.A. 2013 Paleoantropologiya Volgo-Uraliya epokh neolita i bronzy. Dr. Sci. (History) Dissertation. IEA RAN. Moscow.
18. Khokhlov A.A. 2017 Morfogeneticheskiye protsessy v Volgo-Uraliye v epokhu rannego golotsena (po kraniologicheskim materialam mezolita – bronzovogo veka). Samara: Izd. Samar. Gos. Sots.-Ped. Univ.
19. Khokhlov A.A., Grigoryev A.P. 2021 Kraniologicheskiye materialy iz pogrebeniy abashevskoi kultury finala srednei bronzy Povolzhiya i Priuraliya. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Istoriya, No. 69: 132–139.
20. Khokhlov A.A., Kitov E.P. 2019 Teoreticheskiye i prakticheskiye aspekty problemy proiskhozhdeniya fizicheskogo oblika nositelei kultur sintashtinskogo kruga pozdnego etapa epokhi bronzy. Povolzhskaya arkheologiya, No. 1: 59–71.
21. Khokhlov A.A., Kitov E.P., Kapinus Y.O. 2020 K probleme antropologicheskikh svyazei mezhdu nositelyami srubnoi i alakulskoi kultur pozdnego etapa epokhi bronzy v Yuzhnom Priuraliye i zapadnokazakhstanskikh stepyakh. Vestnik Volgogradskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ser. 4: Istoriya. Regionovedeniye. Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, vol. 25 (4): 66–83.
22. Khudaverdyan A.A. 2009 Naseleniye Armyanskogo nagoriya v epokhu bronzy: Etnogenez i etnicheskaya istoriya. Yerevan: Van Ariyan.
23. Kiryushin Y.F., Solodovnikov K.N. 2010 The origins of the Andronovo (Fedorovka) population of southwestern Siberia, based on a Middle Bronze Age cranial series from the Altai forest-steppe zone. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 38 (4): 122–142.
24. Kitov E.P. 2011 Paleoantropologiya naseleniya Yuzhnogo Urala epokhi bronzy. Cand. Sci. (History) Dissertation. IEA RAN. Moscow.
25. Korochkova O.N. 1993 O fedorovskoi culture. In Problemy kulturogeneza i kulturnoye naslediye. Materialy konf., pt. 2. St. Petersburg: IIMK RAN, pp. 84–87.
26. Kozintsev A.G. 2000 On the biological affinities and origin of the Northern Pontic Scythians. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, No. 3: 145–152.
27. Kozintsev A.G. 2004 Kety, uraltsy, “amerikanoidy”: Integratsiya kraniometri- cheskikh i kranioskopicheskikh dannykh. In Paleoantropologiya, etnicheskaya antropologiya, etnogenez: K 75-letiyu Ilyi Iosifovicha Gokhmana. St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 172–185.
28. Kozintsev A.G. 2008 The “Mediterraneans” of Southern Siberia and Kazakhstan, Indo-European migrations, and the origin of the Scythians: A multivariate craniometric analysis. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 36 (4): 140–144.
29. Kozintsev A.G. 2009 Craniometric evidence of the early Caucasoid migrations to Siberia and Eastern Central Asia, with reference to the Indo- European problem. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 37 (4): 125–136.
30. Kozintsev A.G. 2017 Proiskhozhdeniye zapadnykh alakultsev (ob odnoi zatyanuvsheisya diskussii). In Radlovskiy sbornik: Nauchnye issledovaniya i muzeinye proekty MAE RAN v 2016 g. St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 277–287.
31. Kozintsev A. 2019 Proto-Indo-Europeans: The prologue. Journal of Indo- European Studies, vol. 47 (3/4): 293–380.
32. Kozintsev A.G. 2020 The origin of the Okunev population, Southern Siberia: The evidence of physical anthropology and genetics. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 48 (4): 135–145.
33. Kozintsev A.G. 2021 Patterns in the population history of Northern Eurasia from the Mesolithic to the Early Bronze Age, based on craniometry and genetics. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 49 (4): 121–132.
34. Kruts S.I. 1984 Paleoantropologicheskiye issledovaniya Stepnogo Pridneproviya (epokha bronzy). Kiev: Nauk. dumka.
35. Kruts S.I. 2017 Skify stepei Ukrainy po antropologicheskim dannym. Kiev, Berlin: Izd. Oleg Filyuk. (Kurgany Ukrainy; vol. 5).
36. Litvinenko R.A. 2003 Yuzhno-uralskiy ochag kulturogeneza i kultura Babino (KMK): Problema vzaimosvyazi. In Abashevskaya kulturno- istoricheskaya obshchnost: Istoki, razvitiye, naslediye: Materialy Mezhdunar. konf. Cheboksary: Chuvash. gos. inst. gumanit. nauk, pp. 145–152.
37. Narasimhan V., Patterson N., Moorjani P., Rohland N., Bernardos R., Mallick S., Lazaridis I., Nakatsuka N., Olalde I., Lipson M., Kim A., Olivieri L., Coppa A., Vidale M., Mallory J., Moiseyev V., Kitov E., Monge J., Adamski N., Alex N., Broomandkhoshbacht N., Candilio F., Callan K., Cheronet O., Culleton B., Ferry M., Fernandes D., Freilich S., Gamarra B., Gaudio D., Hajdinjak M., Harney É., Harper T., Keating D., Lawson M., Mah M., Mandl K., Michel M., Novak M., Oppenheimer J., Rai N., Sirak K., Slon V., Stewardson K., Zalzala F., Zhang Z., Akhatov G., Bagashev A., Bagnera A., Baitanayev B., Bendezu-Sarmiento J., Bissembaev A., Bonora G., Chargynov T., Chikisheva T., Dashkovskiy P., Derevianko A., Dobeš M., Douka K., Dubova N., Duisengali M., Enshin D., Epimakhov A., Fribus A., Fuller D., Goryachev A., Gromov A., Grushin S., Hanks B., Judd M., Kazizov E., Khokhlov A., Krygin A., Kupriyanova E., Kuznetsov P., Luiselli D., Maksudov F., Mamedov A., Mamirov T., Meiklejohn C., Merrett D., Micheli R., Mochalov O., Mustafokulov S., Nayak A., Pettener D., Potts R., Razhev D., Rykun M., Sarno S., Savenkova T., Sikhymbaeva K., Slepchenko S., Soltobaev O., Stepanova N., Svyatko S., Tabaldiev K., Teschler-Nicola M., Tishkin A., Tkachev V., Vasilyev S., Velemínský P., Voyakin D., Yermolayeva A., Zahir M., Zubkov V., Zubova A., Shinde V., Lalueza-Fox C., Meyer M., Anthony D., Boivin N., Thangaraj K., Kennett D., Frachetti M., Pinhasi R., Reich D. 2019 The formation of human populations in South and Central Asia. Science, vol. 365 (6457): 1002–1007. URL: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aat7487
38. Nordqvist N., Heyd V. 2020 The forgotten child of the wider Corded Ware family: Russian Fatyanovo culture in context. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society, vol. 86: 65–93. URL: https://doi.org/10.1017/ppr.2020.9
39. Otroshchenko V.V. 1998 O kulturno-khronologicheskikh gruppakh pogrebeniy Potapovskogo mogilnika. Rossiyskaya arkheologiya, No. 1: 43–53.
40. Romanova G.P. 1991 Paleoantropologicheskiye materialy iz stepnykh raionov Stavropoliya epokhi rannei i srednei bronzy. Sovetskaya arkheologiya, No. 2: 160–170.
41. Rykushina G.V. 2003 Antropologicheskaya kharakteristika naseleniya epokhi bronzy Yuzhnogo Urala po materialam mogilnika Krivoye Ozero. In Vinogradov N.B. Mogilnik bronzovogo veka Krivoye Ozero v Yuzhnom Zauralye. Chelyabinsk: Yuzh.-ural. kn. izd., pp. 345–360.
42. Shevchenko A.V. 1986 Antropologiya naseleniya yuzhnorusskikh stepei v epokhu bronzy. In Antropologiya sovremennogo i drevnego naseleniya evropeiskoi chasti SSSR. Leningrad: Nauka, pp. 121–215.
43. Solodovnikov K.N. 2005 Kraniologicheskiye materialy iz mogilnika andronovskoi kultury Firsovo XIV v svete problem formirovaniya naseleniya Verkhnego Priobiya v epokhu bronzy. In Izucheniye istoriko- kulturnogo naslediya narodov Yuzhnoi Sibiri, iss. 1. Gorno- Altaisk: AKIN, pp. 35–47.
44. Solodovnikov K.N., Kolbina A.V. 2018 Materialy k antropologii sintashtinskoi kultury Turgaiskogo progiba. In XXI Uralskoye arkheologicheskoye soveshchanie, posvyashchennoye 85-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya G.I. Matveyevoi i 70-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya I.B. Vasilieva. Samara: Izd. Samar. Gos. Sots.-Ped. Univ., pp. 167–169.
45. Solodovnikov K.N., Rykun M.P. 2011 Materialy k antropologii pakhomovskoi kultury epokhi bronzy Zapadnoi Sibiri. Vestnik antropologii, No. 19: 112–129.
46. Solodovnikov K.N., Rykun M.P., Loman V.G. 2013 Kraniologicheskiye materialy epokhi bronzy Kazakhstana. Vestnik arkheologii, antropologii i etnografii, No. 3: 113–131.
47. Solodovnikov K.N., Tumen D., Erdene M. 2019 Kraniologiya chemurchekskoi kultury Zapadnoi Mongolii. In Drevnosti Vostochnoi Evropy i Yuzhnoi Sibiri v kontekste svyazei i vzaimodeistviy v evraziyskom kulturnom prostranstve (novye dannye i kontseptsii), vol. 2. St. Petersburg: IIMK RAN, pp. 79–81.
48. Solodovnikov K.N., Tur S.S. 2003 Kraniologicheskiye materialy eluninskoi kultury epokhi rannei bronzy Verkhnego Priobiya. In Kiryushin Y.F., Grushin S.P., Tishkin A.A. Pogrebalnyi obryad naseleniya epokhi rannei bronzy Verkhnego Priobiya (po materialam gruntovogo mogilnika Teleutskiy Vzvoz-1). Barnaul: Izd. Altai. Gos. Univ., pp. 142–176.
49. Tkachev V.V. 2003 Nachalo alakulskoi epokhi v Uralo-Kazakhstanskom regione. In Stepnaya tsivilizatsiya Vostochnoi Evrazii. Vol. 1: Drevniye epokhi. Astana: Kultegin, pp. 109–124.
50. Tur S.S. 2009 Odontologicheskaya kharakteristika naseleniya andronov- skoi kultury Altaya. Izvestiya Altaiskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, No. 4-2: 228–236.
51. Tur S.S. 2011 A nonmetric cranial study of the Andronovo series from the Altai. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 39 (1): 147–155.
52. Tur S.S., Solodovnikov K.N. 2005 Novye kraniologicheskiye materialy iz pogrebeniy karakolskoi kultury epokhi bronzy Gornogo Altaya. In Izucheniye istoriko-kulturnogo naslediya narodov Yuzhnoi Sibiri, iss. 1. Gorno-Altaisk: AKIN, pp. 35–47.
53. Vinogradov N.B. 2011 Stepi Yuzhnogo Urala i Kazakhstana v pervye veka II tys. do n.e. (pamyatniki sintashtinskogo i petrovskogo tipa). Chelyabinsk: Abris.
54. Zubova A.V., Chikisheva T.A., Pozdnyakov D.V. 2014 Antropologicheskiye aspekty genezisa predstavitelei andronovskoi kulturno-istoricheskoi obschnosti. In Arii stepei Evrazii: Epokha bronzy i rannego zheleza v stepyakh Evrazii i na sopredelnykh territoriyakh: Sbornik pamyati Eleny Efimovny Kuzminoi. Barnaul: Izd. Altai. Gos. Univ., pp. 541–554.
Review
For citations:
Kozintsev A.G. Origin of the Andronovans: A Statistical Approach. Archaeology, Ethnology & Anthropology of Eurasia. 2023;51(4):142-151. https://doi.org/10.17746/1563-0110.2023.51.4.142-151
Views:
299
Email this article 