Generate QR code
Open Access
Subscription Access
An Upper Second Molar from Akhshtyrskaya Cave and Population Affinities of the Middle Paleolithic Hominins of the Caucasus
https://doi.org/10.17746/1563-0110.2025.53.2.134-143
Abstract
The Akhshtyrskaya cave site in northwestern Caucasus dates mostly to the Middle Paleolithic. In 1961, during the analysis of faunal assemblage from layer 3a, a permanent upper second molar of Homo (AKH 1) was discovered. Initially, it was attributed to fossil Homo sapiens. Here, we present new findings related to this specimen, specifically to its external and internal morphology, amount of enamel and dentine in the lateral part of its crown, and a comparison of metric and nonmetric characteristics with those of Denisovans, H. ergaster/erectus/georgicus, H. erectus, H. antecessor, H. neanderthalensis, H. sapiens, Middle Pleistocene Homo of Europe, and Middle and Late Pleistocene Homo of China, distinct from H. erectus. At the first stage, frequencies of nonmetric traits were subjected to principal component analysis. At the second stage, obtained PCA scores were integrated with measurements of the same specimens using PC analysis with grouping variable. Results suggest that the molar from Akhshtyrskaya by no means belongs to H. sapiens. Its morphology is very archaic, linking it to mostly Middle Pleistocene hominin teeth from China. The volume of lateral dentine opposes AKH 1 to molars of Late Pleistocene Homo of Europe and those of H. sapiens, revealing a shift toward Denisovans. The specimen likely belongs to an evolutionary line that has thus far not been found in Europe. Probably, it is of Asian origin.
Supporting agencies: This study was carried out under R&D project of the MAE RAS “Centers of Ethno- and Culturogenesis in Eurasia and the Americas in the Pleistocene and Holocene (Physical Anthropology, Archaeology, and Ethnology)”. The AKH 1 molar was studied in the Research Centre for X-ray Diffraction Studies of the Saint-Petersburg State University (Project No. 125021702335-5). The authors express their gratitude to V.A. Shishkina (Saint-Petersburg College of Technologies, Modeling, and Management) for her help in preparing the illustrations.
About the Authors
A. V. Zubova
Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Zubova A.V., Senior Researcher
Universitetskaya nab. 3, St. Petersburg, 199034
V. G. Moiseyev
Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Moiseyev V.G., Senior Researcher
Universitetskaya nab. 3, St. Petersburg, 199034
A. M. Kulkov
Centre for X-ray Diffraction Studies, Saint-Petersburg State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Kulkov A.M., Engineer
Universitetskaya nab. 7–9, St. Petersburg, 199034
S. A. Kulakov
Institute for the History of Material Culture, Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Kulakov S.A., Leading Researcher
Dvortsovaya nab. 18, St. Petersburg, 191186
References
1. Arsuaga J.L., Martínez I., Arnold L.J., Aranburu A., Gracia-Téllez A., Sharp W.D., Quam R.M., Falguères C., Pantoja-Pérez A., Bischoff J., Poza-Rey E., Parés J.M., Carretero J.M., Demuro M., Lorenzo C., Sala N., Martinón-Torres M., García N., Alcázar de Velasco A., Cuenca-Bescós G., Gómez-Olivencia A., Moreno D., Pablos A., Shen C.-C., Rodríguez L., Ortega A.I., García R., Bonmatí A., Bermúdez de Castro J.M., Carbonell E. 2014 Neandertal roots: Cranial and chronological evidence from Sima de los Huesos. Science, vol. 344 (6190): 1358–1363.
2. Bailey S.E. 2002 Neandertal Dental Morphology: Implications for Modern Human Origins: PhD. Dissertation. Arizona State University. Tempe.
3. Bailey S.E., Liu W. 2010 A comparative dental metrical and morphological analysis of a Middle Pleistocene hominin maxilla from Chaoxian (Chaohu), China. Quaternary International, vol. 211 (1/2): 14–23.
4. Benazzi S., Bailey S.E., Mallegni F. 2013 A morphometric analysis of the Neandertal upper second molar Leuca I. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 152 (2): 300–305.
5. Bermúdez de Castro J.M., Rosas A., Nicolás M.E. 1999 Dental remains from Atapuerca-TD6 (Gran Dolina site, Burgos, Spain). Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 37 (3/4): 523–566.
6. Bermúdez de Castro J.M., Xing S., Liu W., García-Campos C., Martín-Frances L., Martínez de Pinillos M., Modesto-Mata M., Martinón-Torres M. 2021 Comparative dental study between Homo antecessor and Chinese Homo erectus: Nonmetric features and geometric morphometrics. Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 161, Art. No. 103087.
7. Cherdyntsev V.V., Alekseev V.A., Kind N.V., Forova V.S., Zavelsky F.O., Sulerzhitsky L.D., Churikova I.V. 1965 Radiouglerodniye daty laboratorii Geologicheskogo instituta (GIN) AN SSSR. Geokhimiya, No. 12: 1410–1422.
8. Gabunia L.K., Tushabramishvili D.M., Vekua A.K. 1977 O zube mustyerskogo cheloveka iz Tsutskhvatskoy peshchernoy sistemy (Zapadnaya Gruziya). Byulleten Komissii po izucheniyu chetvertichnogo perioda, No. 47: 107–111.
9. Gabunia L., Vekua A., Lordkipanidze D. 2001 New human fossils from Dmanisi, Eastern Georgia. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, No. 2: 128–139. (In Russian and English).
10. Ghasidian E., Kafash A., Kehl M., Yousefi M., Heydari-Guran S. 2023 Modelling Neanderthals’ dispersal routes from Caucasus towards east. PLoS ONE, vol. 18 (2), Art. No. e0281978.
11. Gromov A.V., Zubova A.V., Moiseyev V.G. 2017 Antropologicheskiye materialy s poseleniya yankovskoi kultury Cherepakha-13 v Yuzhnom Primorye. In Arkheologiya CIRCUM-PACIFIC: Pamyati Igorya Yakovlevicha Shevkomuda. Vladivostok: Rubezh, pp. 418–449.
12. Hajdinjak M., Fu Q., Hübner A., Petr M., Mafessoni F., Grote S., Skoglund P., Narasimham V., Rougier H., Crevecoeur I., Semal P., Soressi M., Talamo S., Hublin J.-J., Gušić I., Kućan Z., Rudan P., Golovanova L.V., Doronichev V.B., Posth C., Krause J., Korlević P., Nagel S., Nickel B., Slatkin M., Patterson N., Reich D., Prüfer K., Meyer M., Pääbo S., Kelso J. 2018 Reconstructing the genetic history of late Neanderthals. Nature, vol. 555: 652–656.
13. Hlusko L.J., Carlson J.P., Guatelli-Steinberg D., Krueger K.L., Mersey B., Ungar P.S., Defl eur A. 2013 Neanderthal teeth from Moula-Guercy, Ardèche, France. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 151 (3): 477–491.
14. Khaldeeva N.I., Kharlamova N.V., Zubov A.A. 2010 Sravnitelnoye odontologicheskoye issledovaniye “klassicheskikh” zapadnoyevropeiskikh neandertaltsev. Vestnik antropologii, iss. 18: 60–87.
15. King T., Compton T., Rosas A., Andrews P., Yepiskoposyan L., Asryan L. 2016 Azokh cave hominin remains. In Azokh Cave and the Transcaucasian Corridor. Vertebrate Paleobiology and Paleoanthropology, Y. Fernández-Jalvo, T. King, L. Yepiskoposyan, P. Andrew (eds.). Cham: Springer, pp. 103–116.
16. Kulakov S.A. 2005 Noviye danniye po stratigrafi i i khronologii Akhshtyrskoy peshchernoy stoyanki (Severo-Zapadniy Kavkaz). In Chetvertaya Kubanskaya arkheologicheskaya konferentsiya: Tezisy i doklady. Krasnodar: (s.n.), pp. 158–161.
17. Kulakov S.A. 2015 Akhshtyrskaya peshchernaya stoyanka – “oporniy pamyatnik” srednego paleolita Severo-Zapadnogo Kavkaza? In Drevniye kultury Vostochnoy Yevropy: Etalonniye pamyatniki i oporniye kompleksy v kontekste sovremennykh arkheologicheskikh issledovaniy. St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 25–39. (Zamyatninskiy sbornik; iss. 4).
18. Kulakov S.A., Baryshnikov G.F., Levkovskaya G.M. 2007 Nekotoriye rezultaty novogo izucheniya Akhshtyrskoy peshchernoy stoyanki (Zapadniy Kavkaz). In Kavkaz i pervonachalnoye zaseleniye chelovekom Starogo Sveta. St. Petersburg: IIMK RAN, pp. 65–81.
19. Liao W., Xing S., Li D., Martinón-Torres M., Wu X., Soligo C., Bermúdez de Castro J.M., Wang W., Liu W. 2019 Mosaic dental morphology in a terminal Pleistocene hominin from Dushan Cave in southern China. Scientifi c Reports, vol. 9: 1–14.
20. Liu W., Martinón-Torres M., Cai Y.-J., Xing S., Tong H.-W., Pei S.-W., Sier M.J., Wu X.-H., Edwards R.L., Cheng H., Li Y., Yang X.-X., Bermúdez de Castro J.M., Wu X.-J. 2015 The earliest unequivocally modern humans in southern China. Nature, vol. 526: 696–699.
21. Lyubin V.P. 1997 Homo erectus – pervootkryvatel Yevrazii. Priroda, No. 11: 3–12.
22. Martín-Francés L., Bermúdez de Castro J.M., Martínez de Pinillos M., Martinón-Torres M., Arsuaga J.L. Bertrand B., Vialet A. 2022 Middle Pleistocene hominin teeth from Biache-SaintVaast, France. Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences, vol. 14, Art. No. 215.
23. Martín-Francés L., Martinón-Torres M., Martínez de Pinillos M., García-Campos C., Modesto-Mata M., Zanolli C., Rodrígues L., Bermúdez de Castro J.M. 2018 Tooth crown tissue proportions and enamel thickness in Early Pleistocene Homo antecessor molars (Atapuerca, Spain). PLoS ONE, vol. 13 (10), Art. No. e0203334.
24. Martín-Francés L., Martinón-Torres M., Martínez de Pinillos M., García-Campos C., Zanolli C., Bayle P., Modesto-Mata M., Arsuaga J.L., Bermúdez de Castro J.M. 2020 Crown tissue proportions and enamel thickness distribution in the Middle Pleistocene hominin molars from Sima de los Huesos (SH) population (Atapuerca, Spain). PLoS ONE, vol. 15 (6), Art. No. e0233281.
25. Martinón-Torres M., Bermúdez de Castro J.M., Gómez-Robles A., Margvelashvili A., Prado L., Lordkipanidze D., Vekua A. 2008 Dental remains from Dmanisi (Republic of Georgia): Morphological analysis and comparative study. Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 55 (2): 249–273.
26. Martinón-Torres M., Bermúdez de Castro J.M., Gómez-Robles A., Prado-Simón L., Arsuaga J.L. 2012 Morphological description and comparison of the dental remains from Atapuerca-Sima de los Huesos site (Spain). Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 62 (1): 7–58.
27. Molnar S. 1971 Human tooth wear, tooth function and cultural variability. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 34 (2): 175–189.
28. Ni X., Ji Q., Wu W., Shao Q., Ji Y., Zhang C., Liang L., Ge J., Guo Z., Li J., Li Q., Grun R., Stringer C. 2021 Massive cranium from Harbin in northeastern China establishes a new Middle Pleistocene human lineage. The Innovation, vol. 2 (3): 100–130.
29. Olejniczak A.J. 2006 Micro-Computed Tomography of Primate Molars: Ph.D. Diss. Stony Brook University. New York.
30. Peshchera Matuzka. 2006 L.V. Golovanova, V.B. Doronichev, G.M. Levkovskaya, S.P. Lozovoy, S.A. Nesmeyanov, G.A. Pospelova, G.P. Romanova, V.M. Kharitonov. St. Petersburg: Ostrovityanin.
31. Picin A., Hajdinjak M., Nowaczewska W., Benazzi S., Urbanowski M., Marciszak A., Fewlass H., Bosch M.D., Socha P., Stefaniak K., Żarski M., Wiśniewski A., Hublin J.-J., Nadachowski A., Talamo S. 2020 New perspectives on Neanderthal dispersal and turnover from Stajnia Cave (Poland). Scientific Reports, vol. 10, Art. No. 14778.
32. Pinhasi R., Nioradze M., Tushabramishvili N., Lordkipanidze D., Pleurdeau D., Moncel M.-H., Adler D.S., Stringer C., Higham T.F.G. 2012 New chronology for the Middle Palaeolithic of the southern Caucasus suggests early demise of Neanderthals in this region. Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 63 (6): 770–780.
33. Sarig R., Fornai C., Pokhojaev A., May H., Hans M., Latimer B., Barzilai O., Quam R., Weber G.W. 2021 The dental remains from the Early Upper Paleolithic of Manot Cave, Israel. Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 160 (8), Art. No. 102648.
34. Turner C.J.II, Nichol C.R., Scott G.R. 1991 Scoring procedures for key morphological traits of the permanent dentition: The Arizona State University Dental anthropology system. In Advances in Dental Anthropology. New York: Wiley-Liss Inc., pp. 13–31.
35. Vekilova E.A., Grichuk V.P., Gubonina Z.P., Ermolova A.M., Zubov A.A., Muratov V.M., Fridenberg E.O. 1978 Akhshtyrskaya peshchera. In Arkheologiya i paleogeografiya rannego paleolita Kryma i Kavkaza. Moscow: Nauka, pp. 37–48.
36. Vekilova E.A., Zubov A.A. 1972 Antropologicheskiye ostatki iz mustyerskikh sloyev Akhshtyrskoy peschery. KSIA, iss. 131: 61–65.
37. Weidenreich F. 1937 The Dentition of Sinanthropus Pekinensis: A Comparative Odontography of the Hominids. Peking: Geological Survey of China. (Palaeontologia Sinica. New Ser. D; No. 1).
38. Wu X.-J., Pei S.-W., Cai Y.-J., Tong H.-W., Li Q., Dong Z., Sheng J.-C., Jin Z.-T., Ma D.D., Xing S., Li X.-L., Cheng X., Cheng H., de la Torre I., Edwards R.L., Gong X.-C., An Z.-S., Trinkaus E. 2019 Archaic human remains from Hualongdong, China, and Middle Pleistocene human continuity and variation. PNAS, vol. 116 (20): 9820–9824.
39. Xing S., Martinón-Torres M., Bermúdez de Castro J.-M., Wu X., Liu W. 2015 Hominin teeth from the early Late Pleistocene site of Xujiayao, Northern China. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 156 (2): 224–240.
40. Xing S., Sun C., Martinon-Torres M., Bermúdez de Castro J.M., Han F., Zhang Y., Liu W. 2016 Hominin teeth from the Middle Pleistocene site of Yiyuan, Eastern China. Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 95: 33–54.
41. Zamyatnin S.N. 1961 Ocherki po paleolitu. Moscow, Leningrad: Nauka.
42. Zanolli C., Martinón-Torres M., Bernardini F., Boschian G., Coppa A., Dreossi D., Mancini L., Martínez de Pinillos M., Martín-Francès L., Bermúdez de Castro J.M., Tozzi C., Tuniz C., Macchiarelli R. 2018 The Middle Pleistocene (MIS 12) human dental remains from Fontana Ranuccio (Latium) and Visogliano (FriuliVenezia Giulia), Italy: A comparative high-resolution endostructural assessment. PLoS ONE, vol. 13 (10), Art. No. e0189773.
43. Zubov A.A. 2006 Metodicheskoye posobiye po antropologicheskomu analizu odontologicheskikh materialov. Moscow: Etnoonlain.
44. Zubova A.V., Chikisheva T.A., Shunkov M.V. 2017 The morphology of permanent molars from the Paleolithic layers of Denisova Cave. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 45 (1): 121–134. (In Russian and English).
45. Zubova A.V., Kulkov A.M., Moiseyev V.G., Khartanovich V.I. 2018 Rezultaty ispolzovaniya virtualnogo 3D-modelirovaniya pri izuchenii odontologicheskikh nakhodok epokhi paleolita iz kollektsiy MAE RAN. In Virtualnaya arkheologiya (s vozdukha, na zemle, pod vodoy i v muzeye): Materialy Mezhdunar. foruma. St. Petersburg: Gos. Ermitazh, pp. 58–64.
46. Zubova A.V., Moiseyev V.G., Khartanovich V.I. 2017 Nekotoriye itogi issledovaniya izolirovannykh odontologicheskikh nakhodok epokhi paleolita iz kollektsiy MAE RAN. In Radlovskiy sbornik: Nauchniye issledovaniya i muzeyniye proyekty MAE RAN v 2016 g. St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 253–262.
47. Zubova A.V., Moiseyev V.G., Kulkov A.M., Otcherednoy A.K., Markin S.V., Kolobova K.A. 2022 Maxillary second molar from the Rozhok I Micoquian site (Azov Sea region): Another link between Eastern Europe and Siberia. Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 168, Art. No.103209.
Review
For citations:
Zubova A.V., Moiseyev V.G., Kulkov A.M., Kulakov S.A. An Upper Second Molar from Akhshtyrskaya Cave and Population Affinities of the Middle Paleolithic Hominins of the Caucasus. Archaeology, Ethnology & Anthropology of Eurasia. 2025;53(2):134-143. https://doi.org/10.17746/1563-0110.2025.53.2.134-143
Views:
67
Email this article 